#1 Since 1963

Portions are big! We ordered a small pizza and six garlic knots. Both were good and there are plenty of leftovers. I’m not a huge garlic Knot person but my wife said they were great. Pizza was just what I wanted. A little greasy but it’s NY style pizza. Made that way on purpose.

I always get the personal steak sub and it is always amazing. Everytime I go there in a timely fashion. Everytime I go there the staff is so nice. One time I was in there and I dropped my bag of food because I had gotten 4 things and it was all in one bag. I was so embarrassed cause it was so loud but the staff there was so sweet they asked if it was okay and if I wanted new ones. I said no and they gave me some extra cookies just to make up for me being clumsy. It was amazing.

We love Pudgie’s! Best pizza hands down. The staff is always friendly and helpful. Pizza is made really fast and fresh. The truck drivers are alwsys in and out and they are a little loud and demanding but the staff handles them so well and always has smiles.

“LOVE Pudgie’s Pizza!!! Attended Mansfield University over 40 years ago when I was first introduced to Pudgie’s party pizzas. The staple of every college student, at least back then.
There are none where I currently live, but when I’m up north at my family cabin in PA or my sons in the Elmira area I must have pizza from Pudgie’s! Brings back many good memories and it’s still delicious!

We always get take out, but the store is large and clean. Our food is always ready for the promised time and the employees have always been very friendly and courteous.
If you like pizza like I do and you’re in the Elmira, NY area you have to stop by!

“Tasty pizza and fast delivery! Ordered ahead for a birthday party for delivery at 3pm and they were right on time. Pizza had a light, crispy crust and was really good.”

Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 

“My Team was involved in a shut down at a local Manufacturer. Work was outside in the cold. Pizza and Wings were hot and very tasty. Crew really enjoyed.”

“Pudgies Southside never disappoints. We ordered our usual, a large pizza with extra sauce, meatsauce and pepperoni. We definitely got our extra sauce, perfect! The meatsauce is always delicious. It’s not just a beef topping like everyone else does, this is something else, it’s special and it’s like nobody else can do it. The pepperoni is really good too, the edges curl up a little giving it a bit of crispiness which is awesome. It’s a drive, it might cost a little more, but it’s worth it for a good pizza.”